What Is the Difference Between Yield Maintenance and Defeasance in a Commercial Real Estate Loan?

by | Nov 22, 2026 | Article

What Is the Difference Between Yield Maintenance and Defeasance in a Commercial Real Estate Loan?

Short Answer: Yield maintenance and defeasance are two ways a commercial lender protects the interest income it expected to earn if the borrower pays off a fixed-rate loan early. With yield maintenance, the borrower pays a cash premium designed to make the lender whole for lost interest, usually subject to a minimum. With defeasance, the borrower does not repay the loan at all; it substitutes a portfolio of government securities that produces the remaining payments, and the property is released from the mortgage.

Most borrowers focus on interest rate, term, and leverage when negotiating a commercial loan. The prepayment provision often receives less attention, even though it can determine whether a sale or refinancing makes economic sense years later. A borrower that expects to hold a property for the full loan term may never encounter it; a borrower that sells early or wants to refinance into a better market can find that the cost of exiting the loan is one of the largest numbers in the transaction.

Lenders, for their part, price fixed-rate loans on the assumption that they will receive a stream of interest payments for a defined period. In securitized lending, that stream has often been sold to bondholders who bargained for it. Prepayment provisions protect that expectation. Understanding how yield maintenance and defeasance work, and where there is room to negotiate, matters to both sides at origination and again at exit.

How Does Yield Maintenance Work?

Yield maintenance requires the borrower to pay a premium, in addition to the outstanding principal, equal to the economic loss the lender suffers by being repaid early. In general terms, the calculation compares the remaining scheduled payments on the loan to what the lender could earn by reinvesting the repaid principal in Treasury securities of a comparable maturity, and discounts the difference to present value.

The key variables are the loan’s interest rate, the remaining term (or the time remaining until the loan’s open prepayment period), and the Treasury yield used as the reinvestment rate. When Treasury yields have fallen since the loan was made, the premium can be substantial. When Treasury yields have risen above the loan rate, the formula may produce little or no premium, which is why most loan documents set a minimum, often 1% of the outstanding balance.

Yield maintenance is common in loans from life insurance companies and in some securitized and balance-sheet loans. It is administratively simple: the servicer calculates the amount, and the borrower pays cash at payoff.

How Does Defeasance Work?

Defeasance replaces the real estate collateral rather than paying off the loan. The borrower purchases a portfolio of U.S. Treasury securities (and, if the loan documents permit, certain government agency securities) whose scheduled payments match the remaining debt service on the loan through maturity or through the start of the open period. The securities are pledged to the lender, the mortgage on the property is released, and the loan, now secured by the securities, is typically assumed by a newly formed single-purpose successor borrower.

Defeasance is most closely associated with commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) loans, because it preserves the cash flow that bondholders expect and avoids an actual prepayment of the securitized loan. Securitized loans also commonly include a lockout period after closing during which defeasance is not permitted.

The process involves more participants and cost than yield maintenance. A borrower typically engages a defeasance consultant to structure the securities portfolio and coordinate the closing, and bears the fees of the servicer and its counsel, an accountant certifying that the securities are sufficient, a securities intermediary, the successor borrower, and sometimes rating agency review. A defeasance commonly takes 30 to 45 days to complete.

How Do Interest Rate Movements Affect Each Option?

When rates fall, both options become expensive: the lender’s reinvestment rate is lower than the loan rate, so yield maintenance produces a larger premium, and the Treasury securities needed for defeasance cost more.

When rates rise, the two diverge. Yield maintenance typically declines toward its minimum, so the floor limits how much the borrower benefits. Defeasance has no floor. If Treasury yields exceed the loan rate, the securities portfolio can cost less than the outstanding loan balance, and depending on the loan documents, the borrower may capture that difference. For this reason, borrowers in a rising rate environment sometimes find defeasance less costly than they expected, while lenders and investors find yield maintenance more protective.

What Alternatives Exist?

Not every loan uses either mechanism. Bank loans often use a step-down prepayment premium, such as a percentage of the prepaid amount that declines each year (for example, 3%, 2%, then 1%). Many loans also permit prepayment without premium during an open window near maturity, commonly the last several months of the term. A buyer’s assumption of the existing loan can avoid prepayment entirely, subject to lender approval, assumption fees, and the buyer’s willingness to take the loan’s terms.

Key Drafting Considerations

For Borrowers

  • Open period. Negotiate the longest practical open window before maturity, and make sure defeasance is required only through the start of that window, not to maturity.
  • Discount rate. For yield maintenance, a discount rate of the Treasury yield plus a spread reduces the premium compared with a “Treasury flat” rate.
  • Minimum premium. Seek a lower minimum or no minimum, particularly in a rising rate environment.
  • Choice of method. Where possible, obtain the right to choose between yield maintenance and defeasance at the time of exit.
  • Defeasance mechanics. Seek the right to use agency securities, to designate the successor borrower, and to retain any excess value in the securities portfolio.
  • Involuntary prepayments. Provide that prepayments from casualty insurance proceeds or condemnation awards are not subject to a premium.
  • Partial release. If the property may be sold in parcels, negotiate a partial release or partial defeasance right with a defined release price.

For Lenders

  • Protect the expected yield. A minimum premium and a clearly defined discount rate preserve the economics on which the loan was priced.
  • Address acceleration. State expressly whether the premium is payable if the loan is accelerated after a default, since some courts will not imply that obligation.
  • Control the defeasance process. Specify eligible securities, required certifications, rating agency confirmations where applicable, and the borrower’s obligation to pay all costs.

How Does Massachusetts Treat Prepayment Premiums?

Massachusetts limits prepayment charges on certain residential mortgage loans, including loans on dwellings of four or fewer units (M.G.L. c. 183, § 56), but that statute does not govern typical commercial loans. For commercial loans, enforceability generally turns on the language of the loan documents. In particular, Massachusetts courts have declined to require payment of a prepayment premium following acceleration where the note did not clearly provide for it. Lenders should state expressly that the premium applies to any payment after acceleration, and borrowers should review that language carefully.

Final Thoughts

Yield maintenance and defeasance both allocate interest rate risk on early repayment to the borrower, but they do so differently. Yield maintenance is simpler and cash-based, with a floor that protects the lender when rates rise. Defeasance is more complex and costly to execute, but it can work in the borrower’s favor in a rising rate environment. Because the cost of exiting a fixed-rate loan can affect the economics of a future sale or refinancing, both parties benefit from negotiating the open period, discount rate, minimum premium, and defeasance mechanics carefully at origination, when the borrower has the most leverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is defeasance cheaper than yield maintenance?

It depends on interest rates at the time of exit. When Treasury yields are well below the loan rate, both are expensive. When yields are above the loan rate, yield maintenance usually falls to its minimum premium, while defeasance may cost less than the loan balance, though defeasance also carries significant transaction costs.

How is a yield maintenance premium calculated?

In general, the premium equals the present value of the interest the lender will lose by being repaid early, measured by comparing the loan’s remaining payments to what the lender could earn by reinvesting in Treasury securities of similar maturity. Loan documents specify the exact formula, the reference Treasury, the discount rate, and any minimum premium, so the calculation varies from loan to loan.

Can I pay off a CMBS loan early without a penalty?

Usually only during an open period near the end of the term, which commonly runs for the last few months of the loan. Before that, CMBS loans generally require defeasance or yield maintenance, and many prohibit any prepayment or defeasance during an initial lockout period.

Does a prepayment premium apply if the lender accelerates the loan?

It depends on the loan documents and the governing law. Many lenders draft the premium to apply to any repayment after acceleration, but if the documents do not clearly say so, a court may not enforce the premium following a default. Borrowers and lenders should review that language specifically.

Related Posts