Can a Commercial Tenant Audit the Landlord’s Operating Expense Statement? Audit Rights in Commercial Leases

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Article

Can a Commercial Tenant Audit the Landlord’s Operating Expense Statement? Audit Rights in Commercial Leases

Most commercial leases require tenants to pay a share of the building’s operating expenses, real estate taxes, and insurance costs, either in addition to base rent or to the extent those costs exceed a base year. Each year, the landlord delivers a statement reconciling the tenant’s estimated payments against the actual costs, and the tenant either pays the shortfall or receives a credit for the overpayment.

For many tenants, operating expenses are a significant part of the total occupancy cost, and the annual statement is often the only information they receive about how those costs were calculated. Errors are not uncommon: costs that the lease excludes may be included, capital expenditures may be passed through improperly, the gross-up calculation may be wrong, or the tenant’s proportionate share may be miscalculated. The tenant’s main protection is the right to review and audit the landlord’s books and records.

This post looks at how operating expense audit provisions typically work, what landlords and tenants each negotiate for, and the drafting issues to look for when reviewing the audit section of a commercial lease.

How a Typical Audit Provision Works

Most audit provisions follow a similar structure:

  1. The landlord delivers an annual statement of actual operating expenses within a specified period after the end of each year.
  2. The tenant has a limited window after receiving the statement to give notice that it disputes the statement or wishes to review the landlord’s records.
  3. The landlord makes its books and records relating to operating expenses for that year available for inspection, usually at the landlord’s or property manager’s office during business hours.
  4. If the audit reveals an overcharge, the landlord refunds or credits the overpayment. If the overcharge exceeds a specified threshold, the landlord also reimburses the tenant’s reasonable audit costs.
  5. If the tenant does not object within the review window, the statement becomes final and binding.

The details of each step are where most of the negotiation happens.

The Review Window

The length of time a tenant has to dispute an annual statement is one of the most important terms in the provision. Landlords often propose short windows, such as 30 or 45 days after the statement is delivered, because they want finality and because they need to reconcile their own books, report to lenders and investors, and in some cases calculate expense recoveries for a sale.

Tenants typically seek longer periods, sometimes as long as several months, because organizing an audit takes time and many tenants do not focus on the statement until long after it arrives. A short window combined with a provision that an unchallenged statement is “final and binding” can effectively eliminate the tenant’s audit right in practice.

Who May Perform the Audit

Landlords frequently restrict who may conduct the audit. A common restriction is to prohibit the use of auditors who are compensated on a contingency-fee basis.

Cost-Shifting Thresholds

Audits are expensive, and most leases provide that the tenant bears the cost of its own audit unless the audit reveals a meaningful overcharge. A typical provision requires the landlord to reimburse the tenant’s reasonable audit costs if the tenant’s share of operating expenses was overstated by more than a specified percentage, commonly in the range of 3% to 10%.

Key Drafting Considerations

What Records Are Covered

The lease should specify which books and records the tenant may review. Landlords generally seek to limit the review to records relating to the operating expenses for the year under audit. Tenants may want access to records for prior years as well, particularly where the lease uses a base year, since an error in the base year calculation can affect every subsequent year of the lease term.

Confidentiality

Landlords typically require the tenant and its auditor to keep the results of the audit confidential. This is a reasonable request, since a landlord does not want one tenant’s audit findings shared with the rest of the building. Tenants should make sure the confidentiality obligation includes customary exceptions for disclosures to the tenant’s attorneys, accountants, and lenders, and disclosures required by law or in a dispute with the landlord.

Resolving Disputes Over Audit Results

The landlord and tenant may disagree about whether the audit findings are correct. Some leases provide for a second, binding audit by an independent accountant selected by both parties, although leases differ on which party is responsible for bearing the cost of the independent accountant. Others leave the dispute to ordinary litigation. A defined dispute resolution mechanism can avoid a costly fight over relatively modest sums.

Payment Pending the Audit

Leases commonly require the tenant to pay the amount shown on the annual statement while the audit is pending, without prejudice to its right to a refund. Tenants should confirm that paying the disputed amount does not waive the tenant’s objection.

Frequency and Look-Back

Landlords often limit tenants to one audit per year and prohibit re-auditing a year that has already been audited. Tenants should consider whether the lease gives the landlord a corresponding limit on its ability to issue corrected statements and collect additional amounts for prior years. Many leases give the landlord the right to correct errors in prior statements, and tenants sometimes negotiate for a deadline on that right as well.

Final Thoughts

An operating expense audit right is only as useful as the terms that govern it. A short review window, broad restrictions on who may conduct the audit, and a high cost-shifting threshold can make the right difficult to use in practice. From a landlord’s perspective, reasonable limits provide finality and protect against disruptive or speculative audits.

As with most provisions in a commercial lease, the right balance depends on the size of the tenant’s share of operating expenses and the complexity of the building’s expense structure. Clear drafting on timing, access, costs, and dispute resolution will go a long way toward ensuring that both parties have confidence in the annual reconciliation.

Related Posts