The Deposit as “Sole and Exclusive Remedy”: Liquidated Damages Clauses in Commercial Purchase and Sale Agreements

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Article

The Deposit as “Sole and Exclusive Remedy”: Liquidated Damages Clauses in Commercial Purchase and Sale Agreements

Nearly every commercial real estate purchase and sale agreement (“PSA”) requires the buyer to post a deposit, and nearly every PSA says something about what happens to that deposit if the buyer fails to close. In most cases, the answer is that the seller keeps the deposit as liquidated damages, and that retaining the deposit is the seller’s “sole and exclusive remedy” for the buyer’s default.

That language is so common that it often receives little attention during negotiations. But it reflects a significant allocation of risk. The seller gives up the right to sue for its actual damages, which could be larger or smaller than the deposit, in exchange for certainty. The buyer caps its exposure at the amount it has already put at risk. And the details of how the clause is drafted, including what it covers, what it excludes, and what remedies the buyer has if the seller defaults, can matter a great deal if the deal falls apart.

This post looks at how these provisions work, how Massachusetts courts evaluate them, and the drafting issues that buyers and sellers should look for when reviewing the default and remedies section of a PSA.

How the Clause Works

A typical provision states that if the buyer defaults in its obligation to close, the seller’s sole and exclusive remedy is to terminate the agreement and retain the deposit as liquidated damages, and the seller waives any other rights or remedies at law or in equity, including the right to seek specific performance or actual damages.

The rationale is straightforward. At the time the PSA is signed, neither party can predict what the seller’s damages would be if the buyer walked away. Those damages depend on what the property could be sold for months later, how long it would take to find a new buyer, what carrying costs the seller would incur in the meantime, and whether market conditions have changed. A liquidated damages clause replaces that uncertain calculation with an agreed number.

For the buyer, the clause is often more valuable than it first appears. Without it, a buyer that fails to close could face a claim for the difference between the contract price and the price the seller eventually obtains, plus carrying costs and other consequential losses. In a declining market, that exposure could far exceed the deposit.

How Massachusetts Courts Evaluate These Clauses

Massachusetts courts generally enforce liquidated damages provisions in real estate purchase agreements, adopting what is often called the “single look” approach. Under that approach, the court evaluates the clause based on the circumstances at the time the agreement was signed, not with the benefit of hindsight. A liquidated damages clause will generally be enforced if, at the time of contracting, the seller’s potential damages were difficult to determine and the agreed amount was a reasonable forecast of those damages. The clause will not be enforced if the amount is grossly disproportionate to a reasonable estimate of actual damages, in which case it may be treated as an unenforceable penalty.

As a practical matter, this means that a deposit in the range commonly seen in commercial transactions is likely to be enforceable as liquidated damages, while a deposit that is unusually large relative to the purchase price may invite a challenge. Parties negotiating a larger-than-usual deposit, or a deposit that steps up significantly over the course of the transaction, should consider whether the agreement adequately reflects why that amount is a reasonable estimate of the seller’s potential losses.

Seller Default: The Other Side of the Coin

The remedies section of a PSA almost always addresses seller default as well, and those provisions are frequently more contested than the buyer default clause.

A common seller-friendly formulation limits the buyer’s remedies to (1) terminating the agreement and receiving a return of the deposit, or (2) seeking specific performance. Sellers often push to add reimbursement of the buyer’s out-of-pocket costs only up to a modest cap, or to eliminate it entirely.

Buyers frequently push back on several points:

  1. Willful default. A seller that refuses to close because it has received a better offer should not be able to walk away by simply returning the deposit. Buyers often ask that, if specific performance is unavailable because of the seller’s intentional conduct (for example, conveying the property to a third party), the buyer may recover its actual damages.
  2. Reimbursement of costs. A buyer may spend significant sums on due diligence, legal fees, and financing costs. Buyers typically seek reimbursement of those costs, while sellers seek to cap the amount.
  3. Time to bring specific performance. Sellers often require the buyer to file any specific performance action within a short period (for example, 60 or 90 days after the scheduled closing) or waive that remedy. Buyers should make sure the deadline is workable.

Key Drafting Considerations

What the Deposit Covers, and What It Doesn’t

A “sole and exclusive remedy” clause should not be read so broadly that it releases the buyer from obligations that have nothing to do with the failure to close. Sellers typically carve out the buyer’s indemnity obligations arising from property inspections and access, the buyer’s confidentiality obligations, and the buyer’s obligation to restore the property after testing. Without those carve-outs, a buyer that damages the property during due diligence, or discloses confidential information, could argue that the seller’s only remedy is the deposit. Sellers should confirm those carve-outs survive termination; buyers should confirm the carve-outs are limited to those specific obligations.

Post-Closing Obligations

The liquidated damages clause addresses a failure to close. It should not limit either party’s remedies for breaches discovered after closing, such as a breach of a seller representation. Those claims are usually governed by separate survival, cap, and floor provisions, and the remedies section should make clear that it does not override them.

Conditions to the Buyer’s Default

A buyer should make sure the seller’s right to retain the deposit is triggered only by an actual default by the buyer, after any applicable notice and cure period, and not by the failure of a closing condition outside the buyer’s control (such as the seller’s failure to deliver required tenant estoppel certificates or clear title).

Deposit Increases and Hard Deposits

Many commercial PSAs provide for an initial deposit followed by an additional deposit when the due diligence period expires, at which point the deposit “goes hard.” The liquidated damages clause should clearly state that the seller is entitled to the full deposit then on hand, and the agreement should address what happens if the buyer fails to post the additional deposit when due.

Escrow Agent Instructions

The deposit is usually held by an escrow agent, and the escrow provisions will govern how and when the deposit is released if the parties disagree about who defaulted. The liquidated damages clause and the escrow provisions should work together, including the notice the escrow agent must give before releasing funds and what the agent does if the other party objects.

Final Thoughts

The liquidated damages clause is one of the most important risk-allocation provisions in a commercial PSA, even though it is often treated as boilerplate. For sellers, it provides a certain and generally enforceable remedy in exchange for giving up a potentially larger damages claim. For buyers, it caps exposure at the deposit, but only if the clause is drafted with the right scope and the seller default provisions provide meaningful remedies in return.

As with most provisions in a purchase agreement, the details matter. A clear statement of what the deposit covers, appropriate carve-outs, and remedies for seller default that reflect the parties’ actual expectations will go a long way toward avoiding a dispute over the deposit if the transaction does not close.

Related Posts